The NFC West has been one of the best divisions in pro football these last few years. In 2013, Arizona finished third in the division with a 10-6 record, and the division as a whole went 44-22. There’s not so much depth now, but there are still two potential Super Bowl contenders here.
Arizona Cardinals
2015 record: 13-3, right up there with Carolina in how they were playing…until Carolina took them apart in the NFC Championship, anyway.
What’s To Love? So, so much about this team. Safety/corner hybrid Tyrann Mathieu could’ve been a good shout for Defensive Player of the Year had he stayed healthy. Either way, he’s a groundbreaking player who’s establishing a new position, a new way to play in the secondary and a whole new way to think about the secondary, and coverage in general. Arizona have five wide receivers who’d be starters on some other teams. They had a fantastic defense even before trading for Chandler Jones, who was one of the best in the league last year. Bruce Arians has a fantastic record as a head coach, David Johnson is right up there with Todd Gurley in the best running backs to come through the draft in the last couple of years…I could go on.
What’s Not To Love? There’s just a bit of an “and yet…” with the Cardinals. They were fairly poor in beating Green Bay in the playoffs before losing to Carolina, quarterback Carson Palmer in particular having a big dip in quality. Mathieu is a revelation but has had so many serious injuries at such an early point in his career, how can you rely on him? They have Patrick Peterson at cornerback who is a stud, but beyond him,it’s rookies and unproven special teamers. And outside of Jones and 3-4 end Calais Campbell, the front seven is only “fairly good”. So there are a few things, and if Arizona don’t win the Super Bowl this season, these may well be reasons.
What’ll 2016 Be Like Then? That’s the key, isn’t it? “If Arizona don’t win the Super Bowl”. Arizona might well have the best roster of all the Super Bowl contenders, and deserve to be talked about as having a good chance. Their undoing may end up being stuck in the same division as the near-equally excellent Seahawks. Both are contenders, but whoever has the worse record will have the tougher task to get to the Super Bowl. That said, I think Arizona will go 13-3 and that could give them the #1 seed in the NFC they may need to get there.
Seattle Seahawks
2015 record: 10-6, despite starting 2-4. At no point, then, did Seattle look like a 10-6 team. They started up looking like a 6-10 team, and finished up looking like a 14-2 one.
What’s To Love? So, so much about this team. Russell Wilson might be irritating as a person but he became one of the top few quarterbacks in the NFL last year. Doug Baldwin started looking like a #1 receiver, and Tyler Lockett might be the best one from last year’s draft. Thomas Rawls emerged as a star running back. And that’s not even mentioning the defense! Michael Bennett, Earl Thomas, Richard Sherman, Cliff Avril, Kam Chancellor. Just generally be afraid; be very afraid.
What’s Not To Love? If ever a team was built to cope with a shoddy offensive line, it’s Seattle, with a mobile quarterback and running backs adept at making the best of a bad situation. But make no mistake, Seattle’s line is bad. It says a lot when they lose a semi-liability like J.R. Sweezy in free agency, and somehow get worse. I’m not sure there’s a single starting-calibre player on this line, and way too much is hoped for from first-round draft pick Germain Ifedi.
What’ll 2016 Be Like Then? Well, Seattle will probably continue to bait ProFootballFocus by winning lots of games with an awful offensive line. It may cost them a game or two, and it’ll be a bit of a disaster if it leads to Russell Wilson getting injured, but so far so good. The offense is improving to come close to the defense, but it’ll never match it, and Bennett, Thomas and co will continue to get sacks, interceptions, fumbles and every good defensive stat. I think Seattle to match Arizona with 13-3.
St Louis Los Angeles Rams
2015 record: 7-9. Jeff Fisher coached a team to a 7-9 record. I know, I know.
What’s To Love? Aaron Donald and Todd Gurley, basically. Donald is the best defensive lineman not named JJ Watt, is quicker off the mark than pretty much anyone in the trenches on either side of the ball in the NFL. He will get sacks, pressures, you name it. He’s the main reason teams don’t score many points against the Rams. Conversely, Todd Gurley is probably the only reason the Rams will score points this season. A generational talent at running back, he can create something from nothing, can turn 5 yard gains into 30 yard gains, is decent in the passing game too. The only thing is he doesn’t have much of an offensive line to work with.
What’s Not To Love? This is a singularly unloveable franchise outside of those too. They gave up every draft pick ever basically to get Jared Goff, who is now reported to look like the sum of his flaws, not his talents. He doesn’t have any good wide receivers or tight ends to pass to, even if he does play. The defense looks a notch weaker, as the secondary will feel the loss of Janoris Jenkins, you suspect. This is a team out of time that only looks to have what it takes to compete in the NFL on one side of the ball.
What’ll 2016 Be Like Then? You may have seen the clip from Hard Knocks of Jeff Fisher profanely promising to not go 7-9 again. The good news is, the Rams won’t go 7-9! The bad news is, their first season in Los Angeles will be worse than that. I reckon 5-11 is a fair number to predict, with four wins being down to the defense and one to Todd Gurley. This team has been assembled poorly, and coached worse than that.
San Francisco 49ers
2015 record: 5-11, which was considered to be better than expected. That’s how bad things are in San Francisco.
What’s To Love? Er, DeForest Buckner and Arik Armstead might make some nicely terrifying 3-4 defensive end bookends? Wait, do the 49ers even play 3-4 defense?
What’s Not To Love? This just makes me so sad. Jim Harbaugh might have been a bigger arsehole than the size of the universe in No Man’s Sky (tortured metaphor klaxon sounds), but this team has just been torn apart since midway through that 2014 season. They have a worse situation at quarterback than anyone else – Gabbert and Kaepernick should not be starting in the 2016 NFL. Their only good wide receiver can draw pass interference flags and do little else. The 49ers still haven’t recovered from most of their defense retiring, and with Navarro Bowman not looking back to his old self last season, there’s still some way to go. I honestly cannot find a silver lining for this team. At least Cleveland seem to have a rebuilding plan in place.
What’ll 2016 Be Like Then? If Cleveland don’t ‘win’ the first overall pick next year, don’t be surprised if San Francisco do. I look at this roster and I just can’t see how they’re going to win any games. There is just no talent here. Unless Chip Kelly somehow morphs into a good NFL coach (unlike, say, what he was in Philadelphia last year), the 49ers will be lucky to go 3-13.